Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [Problems and Solutions] | draw games[Forum Rules] [Login]

draw games

Thread #1422 - Messages: 26   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 draw games Message #14179    Replies: 1
posted by calypso (calypso) on 01/29 at 17:58
i have sent 2 messages already about a chess game wich has 8! repeated moves already!( which is a DRAW!) BUT, it is still on the boards and i don't want to make any more moves! Ergo, i could loose that Game!( if it is not removed from the active Game list!)my opponent is still making moves! When will this Game ever declaired a Draw and removed? Thanks for looking in to this!
 
 Re: draw games Message #14180    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 01/30 at 09:50
Hi,

Sorry, been a bit snowed under lately. Please be patient, it's a manual process. I assume you have also had your opponent send in a note? (I can't check right now.) If not, we can't declare the game a draw.
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
   
 Re: draw games Message #14181    Replies: 2
posted by tjrm (Jim) on 01/31 at 04:10
The specific case is none of my business of course. My understanding, however, is that Calypso is requesting an adjudication of draw from repetition of moves, because the opponent does not concede that a draw can be claimed. If those are the facts, does your reply, T.J., mean that you would not adjudicate a draw per rules of chess? Or only, perhaps, that you cannot be an Adjudicator because of the time and research required, though recognizing that a draw should be claimable if indeed the repetitions have occurred? If the latter, I would like to suggest the use of volunteer Adjudicators who could review the game and assess the applicability of a claimed rule.
     
 Re: draw games Message #14182    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 01/31 at 08:41
Hi Jim,

If both players are using our non-Java games, they can't end a game in a draw themselves, they need to ask us to do it for them. It's a flaw in our non-Java games. (If only one of the players is using the non-Java games, they can offer the draw and the Java player can acccept.) That's how I read calypso's message, since he was talking about 8 moves. Forcing a draw against a player's wishes requires 30-50 moves in which the player hasn't demonstrated an increase in advantage. Fortunately, most players are reasonable about accepting draws and we've only had to do that twice so far.
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
       
 Re: draw games Message #14184    Replies: 2
posted by tjrm (Jim) on 01/31 at 14:59
T.J.

No longer this case of course, but in chess a draw can be claimed if the exact same position is reached three times. It is a common objective for a player with a meterial disadvantage to force a draw through "perpetual check". This is also a draw, not just the rule from no advantage in 50 moves that you discuss. Note, also, that in a case where the repetition rule applies, it is often the case that the player with the advantage would not wish to grant the draw. There was a notable case from Bobby Fischer in which he was able to claim a draw (3rd time in exact position) from Tigrin Petrosian in which that third time was a number of moves later than the first two times. The adjusticators had to study the game history to grant Fischer his claimed draw.
         
 Re: draw games Message #14185    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/01 at 08:37
Hi Jim,

Yes, I know of that rule. I'm hoping to include it at some point...

-- T.J. :-)
           
 Re: draw games Message #14187    Replies: 1
posted by tjrm (Jim) on 02/01 at 15:19
T.J.:

Ah. No rush!! Truly your accomplishments are astounding. :-)
             
 Re: draw games Message #14189    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/02 at 12:02
Truly your accomplishments are astounding. :-)
*snorts*
         
 Re: draw games Message #14190    Replies: 1
posted by calypso (calypso) on 02/03 at 15:53
SO! here we are at the 90! move! and still playing! lol at the 60. move we had already repeated 4! times the same moves! now,30 moves later,we are still playing! he he he first it was annoying, but now i,m having fun! maybe we break a record here in # of moves played in a chess game! lol
           
 Re: draw games Message #14191    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/04 at 06:51
Why don't you end the game in a draw? You have the ability to do that.
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
             
 Re: draw games Message #14193    Replies: 1
posted by calypso (calypso) on 02/04 at 15:58
sorry, it does not work! am i missing something here? both, my opponent and i have clicked on the 'offer draw' button, about 30 times now, but nothing happens! where is the "accept" or "decline" button? (maybe i'm just dumb? he he he )
               
 Re: draw games Message #14196    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/05 at 07:18
Hi,

That's strange. It does work, if you're using the Java games, which the system tells me both of you are. People do draws all the time.

When it's your turn, click Offer Draw and it'll ask you if you're sure you want to offer to end the game in a draw. If you confirm, it becomes the other player's turn. When they go into the game, a pop-up window asks whether they want to accept or decline.
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
                 
 Re: draw games Message #14212    Replies: 1
posted by calypso (calypso) on 02/07 at 17:07
Sorry again! we are now at the 107!! move and no change! i have not seen any window that says accept or decline,i think that is the problem.
                   
 Re: draw games Message #14214    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/08 at 08:14
Hi,

Either of you can initiate a draw at any time. The next time it's your turn, don't make a move; instead, click the "Offer Draw" button and when it asks if you really want to offer a draw, click OK. When he/she next goes into the game, your opponent will get a question about accepting the draw. If he/she clicks Accept, the game will end in a draw.

-- T.J.
                     
 Re: draw games Message #14219    Replies: 1
posted by calypso (calypso) on 02/09 at 20:59
"When he/she next goes into the game, your opponent will get a question about accepting the draw. If he/she clicks Accept, the game will end in a draw." -- T.J.
-----------
Sorry,it does not work that way at all! both of us do not get this Question at all! all we get is a box where you can accept or decline and that is it! nothing after that! i guess eventually it will be resolved (i hope). lol
                       
 Re: draw games Message #14220    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/09 at 21:12
Hi,

When you go into the game and it's your turn, on the right-hand side, there is a column of buttons. The second button down (just under "Send") is "Offer Draw". Click that when it's your turn. A pop-up message will appear asking if you're sure you want to offer a draw. Click OK.

-- T.J.
                         
 Re: draw games Message #14221    Replies: 2
posted by calypso (calypso) on 02/09 at 21:48
Yes! that is right! and that is what we have been doing all along! but that is where it's ends! no further!
                           
 Re: draw games Message #14222    Replies: 0
posted by daisyheadmaisy (daisyheadmaisy) on 02/09 at 22:39
I have been following this thread and if i'm looking at the correct game - when you look at the turn histoy - look at how the turn information changes from turn 62 on.
                           
 Re: draw games Message #14228    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/10 at 08:51
Well, I can't explain why it works for everyone else using he Java games and not for you. If you both want the game to end in a draw, please write in (both of you) and I'll do it for you.

-- T.J.
                             
 Re: draw games Message #14231    Replies: 1
posted by calypso (calypso) on 02/10 at 22:00
this is the message i got from my opponent after i asked him to send you a message! lol
___________________________________
From: [redacted] Sent: 02/10 15:41 CST
Subject: Draw?

"You should ahve demanded a draw when the position was 3 times repeated, now it is another position."
_________________________________________________________

I am getting a little annoyed at this guy!so far i have kept my mouth shut,but i have played him a few times before and i think he is using a computer to do his moves! he can't stand losing,although our game is only a draw,he will not agree to it! Well,i guess we will play on indefinitely! lol
                               
 Re: draw games Message #14234    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/11 at 09:37
Hi,

(I've redacted the name of the player in the message above. Please review the House Rules.)

Okay, so it sounds to me like it's just that the other player has been declining your draw offers, rather than it not working.

Let's pick this up privately.
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
                                 
 Re: draw games Message #14236    Replies: 1
posted by calypso (calypso) on 02/11 at 16:47
"If a game is clearly a draw, offer the draw or accept it if it's offered!" this is in the house rules! Yet,my opponent refuses to accept! what am i to do? i was never rude to him,in fact. we didn't even speak during the games,other than what was related to THIS game!
                                   
 Re: draw games Message #14237    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/11 at 17:13
Again, let's pick this up privately.

-- T.J.
                                     
 Re: draw games Message #14242    Replies: 1
posted by calypso (calypso) on 02/11 at 19:17
ok, send me a PM.
                                       
 Re: draw games Message #14255    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/14 at 11:27
And the reason turns out to be: That calypso's opponent was declining the draw (he wrote to me separately). They're working it out between them.

-- T.J.
     
 Re: draw games Message #14183    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 01/31 at 09:10
Hi again,

Sorry, for some reason I was thinking Checkers there, but calypso did say it was a Chess game.

It also turns out not to be either the situation I thought it was or that you did, but I can't go into it further here.

-- T.J.

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.