Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [Problems and Solutions] | Closing rolls-backgammon[Forum Rules] [Login]

Closing rolls-backgammon

Thread #1492 - Messages: 7   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 Closing rolls-backgammon Message #14900    Replies: 2
posted by snuffa (Jack) on 06/23 at 17:53
Has any other player experienced what I term as an inordinate number of doubles / key rolls your opponent rolls in the closing (last 4-5) rolls of the game?

I have lost a very high number of games when my opponent rolls key rolls much higher and more consistantly than normal odds would dictate.

I'm only asking as a wonder if there a program issue with the backgammon programming itself.
 
 Re: Closing rolls-backgammon Message #14901    Replies: 1
posted by playBunny (pB) on 06/23 at 23:00
How high is "a very high number of games" and how high is a "much higher than normal odds" number of key rolls?
   
 Re: Closing rolls-backgammon Message #14902    Replies: 1
posted by daisyheadmaisy (daisyheadmaisy) on 06/24 at 01:19
I have had that happen as well - but on my rolls.
     
 Re: Closing rolls-backgammon Message #14903    Replies: 0
posted by magic (dot) on 06/24 at 08:01
yep, I have had it work boths ways also.. I am sure dice are totally random.
 
 Re: Closing rolls-backgammon Message #14904    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 06/24 at 08:02
Hi,
I'm only asking as a wonder if there a program issue with the backgammon programming itself.
It isn't. :-) The part of the site that rolls the dice doesn't know what player or what game the roll is for, much less what stage the game is in. The rolls are random, or as random as realistically possible when using a computer. I wrote up a description of this stuff in a quite lengthy post in this thread.

Most of that post deals with our (e.g., humans') perception of odds, which is intuitively convincing but frequently wrong. That may (or may not!) make interesting reading, but it's the part near the end that I think is relevant to what you're seeing -- I'll quote it here:
We frequently suffer from something my father called "neglect of negative instances". You put your pencil on the table, and it rolls off, and you think "Argh! It's always doing that!" Now, while it may be that it is always doing that (in which case you might consider fixing the table, it's clearly not level), it's much more likely that it only does that sometimes -- it's just you don't notice it when it doesn't roll off the table, because it's a non-event. My mobile phone is always running out of battery power in the middle of an important call. Well, no, probably not, it's just that I haven't noticed the dozens of important calls where it didn't run out of battery power; they were non-events. We humans take note of things that happen that are unusual, and tend to gloss over the usual. With pencils and mobile phone batteries -- and dice rolls! -- this is a fairly innocuous tendency we have. But scientists are taught to be very careful of it, it's an easy trap to fall into. I fell into it just recently here on PM. I was in a game and my opponent was just getting all the rolls, particularly doubles. I was feeling a bit hard done by, to be honest, by the die roller. I hadn't had doubles in ages! But then I thought: Let's go look. And you know what? In that game, my opponent had had six doubles -- and I'd had five. Apparently, to me, his getting doubles was unusual and noteworthy, whereas my getting doubles was just normal. Go figure.
Enjoy your games!
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
   
 Re: Closing rolls-backgammon Message #14905    Replies: 1
posted by snuffa (Jack) on 06/24 at 11:36
TJ...That sums it up quite nicely.
     
 Re: Closing rolls-backgammon Message #14914    Replies: 0
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 06/26 at 03:31
yeah tyhey shouldnt get that many ddls at a time in a game its funny how it happems at the end of a game lol..but its fun playing games win or lose

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.