Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [Problems and Solutions] | opponents[Forum Rules] [Login]

opponents

Thread #1521 - Messages: 8   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 opponents Message #15189    Replies: 1
posted by Purplerose (Rose P.) on 08/02 at 19:49
TJ... is it a possibility for someone to be using a computerized program to be playing for them on their games?
 
 Re: opponents Message #15190    Replies: 3
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 08/02 at 21:25
Sure, it's possible. The most likely way is with any of several programs available that analyze a board position and recommend options. The user has to hand-enter the board position (which isn't hard), and then the computer tells them what their best move is according to the computer's programming.

Doesn't sound like much fun, eh? :-)

Enjoy your games,
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com

   
 Re: opponents Message #15191    Replies: 0
posted by cathm (Cath) on 08/02 at 22:06
you're right, TJ, sure would take the fun out of playing
   
 Re: Computer player Message #15192    Replies: 0
posted by playBunny (pB) on 08/02 at 22:47
It can be taken a stage further. A program can read the game page (using the web version, not java) and determine what the position is. That can then be fed into GnuBg (one of the programs that T.J. mentioned and the most accessible to external scripting) and the move analysis obtained. The move can then be fed back to the website. This is done at various sites, most notably Fibs. Other sites provide in-house bots to play against, eg VogClub.

DailyGammon has two bot accounts, created by users. One has been there for a number of years and has become a very popular opponent. The other, which is mine, is still being developed and is intended to provide services that the original one doesn't, such as post-match analysis (the original one can provide move analysis only), and it'll calculate a "bot rating" which will measures a player's prowess against the bot. A bot account can be a good addition to a site, especially if the bot is online 24x7.

We use the DailyGammon bot for a special Beat the Bot competition where players have to play against it at each match length until they win at that length. Their score is the total number of matches that it takes them to collect a full set of victories. And the winner is the one with fewest matches played.

People who use a bot to make their moves are a strange breed and I don't claim to understand them. One of the top players at BrainKing is a bot player and was discovered to play exactly like GnuBg on its 0-ply setting. Unless the account is programmed, as mentioned above, the person must be a total slave to the bot. There's another at DailyGammon who we strongly suspect of using a bot for his moves; his error rates are simply too good to be true.

It's hard to know what mental distortions must be made to get value out of achievements based on a bot's moves (or on cheating, in its many forms) but clearly some people do.
   
 Re: opponents Message #15193    Replies: 2
posted by Purplerose (Rose P.) on 08/03 at 02:21
Thanks... I do enjoy them. I love PM games. You rock TJ! :)


For all those bot users.... life must be pretty bad if you have to resort to bots to run your life. :)
     
 Re: opponents Message #15194    Replies: 0
posted by cathm (Cath) on 08/03 at 03:53
DUH
     
 Re: opponents Message #15196    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 08/03 at 09:44
Thanks Rose! I never get tired of hearing that people have run here!

-- T.J. :-)
       
 Re: opponents Message #15197    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 08/03 at 10:16
fun, not run -- doh!

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.