Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [Problems and Solutions] | inactive players[Forum Rules] [Login]

inactive players

Thread #1652 - Messages: 33   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 inactive players Message #16363    Replies: 2
posted by chicks (COOL MOVE) on 03/28 at 14:41
funny for sure. there are players on here, that have not even stay on site for a whole day. here where it gets really funny they have been gone for many years.. when your thinking of a cool user name and you have it. it says being used choose another. BUT clearly its not actually being used cos the people arent even here. and havent been here for many years. i guess the reason why they are still on. you need them to be on there. like a quoto. you have wonder how many actual players go to another site cos inactive players has their user name..
 
 Re: inactive players Message #16365    Replies: 2
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 03/28 at 14:51
I'm not quite seeing what you're driving at, but no, we don't need player accounts (like a quota), that's not what we're about.

Allowing new players to reuse old, inactive player names is a recipe for confusion. I hope it's not preventing new people signing up, but if so, well, we're probably going to just live with that.

Enjoy your games,
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
   
 Re: inactive players Message #16369    Replies: 1
posted by playBunny (pB) on 03/30 at 05:01
Certainly a once-active name taken up by a stranger has the potential to cause confusion but a case could be made for recycling names where the player never came back or only stayed for some minimum number of days or games. :-)
     
 Re: inactive players Message #16371    Replies: 2
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 03/30 at 06:19
If it`s not broken........
       
 Re: inactive players Message #16372    Replies: 1
posted by magic (dot) on 03/30 at 12:34
I came back after a long break, and was happy to see my account still there.. I am sure its just fine the way it is.
         
 Re: inactive players Message #16379    Replies: 0
posted by cathm (Cath) on 04/01 at 04:41
i totally agree, Dot; no reason to change a thing
       
 Re: Name recycling Message #16377    Replies: 1
posted by playBunny (pB) on 03/31 at 18:03
If it`s not broken........

And if it is.......? ;o)

Here's an example. Supposing someone came along a few years ago, created an account called gogdog, started a couple of games, didn't care for how things worked and abandoned the account, leaving the matches to be mashed by the time-keeping Gorilla. Now, suppose that gogdog is a very meaningful name that you really wanted. You wouldn't have been able to have it because it would have been already taken. Sure you could have had any other name in the world (that's not in the database) but you couldn't have had the one that you wanted - really wanted. That's what's broken.

I understand the need for name recycling, myself, as playBunny is the name that I want for game sites. I don't want something like playBunny0, as I've had to have elsewhere. "I am not a number, I am a free bun!" When the existing playbunny account at a site is inactive and never got used in the first place it's unavailability is a shame that needn't have to happen.

magic's example provides a pefect contrast. There you have an previously active and still wanted account. Much to magic's joy, it's still available after an extended gap. In her case it would have been a shame if the account had not still been available.

That's the case at GoldToken where it would have turned that into a number account a long time previously. However, a player can ask for their account name to be preserved and GoldToken are happy to do that. That allows previously active accounts to still be there if the player should return. I think I'd implement that if I had a game site, with the difference that characters (people who played and posted a lot and became known) would automatically have their account preserved - as a measure against the potential confusion that TJ pointed out.

Having said all that, we're not talking about a stop-everything-and-fix-this issue, lol, it's just one of many nice subtleties that a site can incorporate. ;-)

While on the topic of names. At BrainKing there is tremendous flexibility. A player can rename their account any time that they like and, if they do, it's possible for another player to steal their original name! Lol, how's that for potential confusion?! ;O)
         
 Re: Name recycling Message #16380    Replies: 1
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 04/01 at 06:09
Think i`ll change mine to McGoohan!
           
 Re: Name recycling Message #16405    Replies: 1
posted by playBunny (pB) on 04/01 at 17:16
That was a pat reply. ;o)
             
 Re: Name recycling Message #16409    Replies: 1
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 04/01 at 18:24
Indeed.
               
 Re: Name recycling Message #17143    Replies: 1
posted by tarzan (haken) on 10/12 at 05:08
maybe a player needs to have a quota of games played to ensure dibs on the name,.. say 10 or 20 completed games shows they are serious and earned the nametag ?.. will help recycle the flybynights and make everone happy ?

                 
 Re: Name recycling Message #17155    Replies: 1
posted by FULL MOON (Moonbeam) on 10/13 at 17:30
I think names that are inactive should be deleted, possibly a time limit would be helpful, I looked in the directory last night and found some inactive for 5 years or longer
                   
 Re: Name recycling Message #17158    Replies: 1
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 10/14 at 02:09
yeah i seen a few are inactive also..but some of them ppl might came back under a different name
                     
 Re: Name recycling Message #17163    Replies: 1
posted by FULL MOON (Moonbeam) on 10/14 at 03:13
I have a player who became idle 7 days ago, usually that is not odd except the same night a new name popped up and seems to be the same person. To me this is rude to keep people hanging on a game while they are playing under the new name.
                       
 Re: Name recycling Message #17167    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 10/14 at 05:57
FULL MOON (Moonbeam) wrote:
I have a player who became idle 7 days ago, usually that is not odd except the same night a new name popped up and seems to be the same person. To me this is rude to keep people hanging on a game while they are playing under the new name.
It would also be a violation of the user agreement, as we only allow a single account per player. If you have a strong reason to think two player accounts are actually the same person, feel free to drop us a note privately telling us the two account names and why you think they're the same person.

Thanks,
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
   
 Re: inactive players Message #17231    Replies: 1
posted by ironmanmv (marc) on 10/20 at 02:01
hi tj
havent talked in a long time.
how about everyone get a new 9 digit number for a name then they got 30 days to make up the name they are so dear to. if they get it they own it and if someone else wants the same name let them use caps, a mix of caps or just at a number after the presious name.
however more important to me is the fact i want to hear the dice roll in the cup and hitting the board. i would like to see pictures on the pieces to.
can you arrange that?
just joking and being a little sarcastic just think when things are free enjoy it why ask to create a burden on someone like you that provides a pleasant place to enjoy games.
and i would be totally amazed if someone left or didnt register with PM because of an online name. those people are still sucken on mamas teet because they are nothing more than babies
again thanx for everything you are doing and providing a great spot to play for FREE!
     
 Re: inactive players Message #17234    Replies: 1
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 10/20 at 07:14
Hey ironman,i have to mirror your statements,T.J. & co do a great job.
       
 Re: inactive players Message #17235    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 10/20 at 09:03
Hi guys,

Thanks for that, very kind!

Free or not, suggestions are always welcome, even criticism if done in the right spirit. :-)

But when this was first suggested (in another thread) I checked, and there just aren't enough genuinely-unused accounts to bother with doing anything about it, not until or unless PM's membership grows by a factor of, oh, about 1,000. People disappear for a year or two and come back, a player's name is all that uniquely identifies them on the site and so recycling them is asking for trouble and confusion, as I've said above.

We might, at some stage, recycle names that have been unused for a long time if they've never played a game and never sent or received an on-site message (and so the opportunities for confusion are low), but it's so low on the priority list...
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
 
 Re: inactive players Message #17169    Replies: 3
posted by Silverwalker (Silverwalker) on 10/14 at 22:28
I have to agree; it would make sense to remove those who have only played a few games and then left, and haven't been here for years.

Typically in a site, the most desirable names are those that are real, such as Eric and Jenny. If someone registers such a name and only plays two games and leaves, then I don't see any harm, but much good, in letting someone else have that name when much time has passed.
   
 Re: inactive players Message #17210    Replies: 0
posted by Rabbits2 (Shirlene Burns) on 10/18 at 02:53
I was inactive simply because I couldn't log on I use a webtv and sometimes it wants to do other things like not work
   
 Re: inactive players Message #17243    Replies: 1
posted by FULL MOON (Moonbeam) on 10/20 at 17:30
Out of pure boredom I checked the first 15 players in the directory under the letter A
1 player is active
1 player moved last December
and the rest have not moved in 3-7 years.
     
 Re: inactive players Message #17245    Replies: 2
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 10/20 at 18:45
Hi,

So two out of 15 active in the last year (we've had lots of players come back after a year way -- or two, or three even), which is about 13%. That's roughly consistent with the numbers I ran a while back. And again: Players do return after a long time away (it's not easy to check, but I recall one with a four-year gap).

In any case, we're not going to reuse a player name even if they've been gone for three years if they did anything while they were here. It's just not worth it. There are billions of player names available (that's actually a severe understatement), we're no where near running out and have about 350 higher-priority things to worry about.

And with that, I bow out of the conversation and leave you to chat amongst yourselves. :-)

Enjoy your games!
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
       
 Re: inactive players Message #17266    Replies: 2
posted by ironmanmv (marc) on 10/21 at 06:45
unless i am blind i tried to post a responce and at the proof lvl i lost it. i guess i should be directly emailing support.
heres a short on my feelings.
1 tj u do to much no other site provides the personal touch like u guys do.
2 to many using the forum are sympathy hunters and only depress the rest of us,'
3 make it a pay site after u give me life time membership so those that want changes as stupid as some have been can feel better even when u dont give a service.
4 create a death and on death bed thread so i dont have to indure the depression of a post from someone needing comforting.
ply the games, enjoy the games, and stop depressing me!
if u gotta ban me tj do so
         
 Re: inactive players Message #17270    Replies: 0
posted by playBunny (pB) on 10/21 at 15:07
I'm sorry to hear that you're depressed, ironmanmv, but you've come to the right place if you're seeking comfort. You have my fullest sympathies in your struggle to rise above others' stupidity. :-)
         
 Re: inactive players Message #17283    Replies: 0
posted by FULL MOON (Moonbeam) on 10/21 at 17:34
This is a good site and it is obvious TJ and all have put in countless hours to give us all entertainment.
One thing we could all recognize is many players are here as their only source of entertainment and conversation. It was brought up on another thread to read profiles, if a person doesn't want to chat or wants minimal chat then include this on your profile. A little compassion for our fellow players goes a long ways.
       
 Re: inactive players Message #18149    Replies: 1
posted by Kimmy (.) on 12/22 at 06:08
Thanks for not deleting me. :)
         
 Re: inactive players Message #18166    Replies: 1
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 12/23 at 07:44
why do ppl like to complain who hasnt played in years..does it bother u that much
           
 Re: inactive players Message #18167    Replies: 1
posted by playBunny (pB) on 12/23 at 11:09
As the original poster said, the names used by dormant/abandoned accounts could be reused.

Other people think that the ratings tables could do without players who haven't been seen in a long time to make space on a very limited resource for the people who are actually playing. In the worst case, the Top 20 could show 20 names that haven't been seen in years and the best current player on the site might be at 21 yet could never be shown.

My question is a different one. Why do people complain about people who see possibilities for improvement?
             
 Re: inactive players Message #18168    Replies: 1
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 12/23 at 15:39
some of them ppl might not have computers anymore n cant get on line anymore
i have seen ppl come n go n never come back

ppl arent happy no matter if its good or bad
they might have a reason not to come back
               
 Re: inactive players Message #18169    Replies: 1
posted by Miami Doll (Mai) on 12/23 at 17:58
chicks is never happy
                 
 Re: inactive players Message #18170    Replies: 1
posted by playBunny (pB) on 12/23 at 20:40
Heh heh. I guess I can't ever be happy either then, because I can think of loads of ideas for the sites that I visit. ;-)
                   
 Re: inactive players Message #18173    Replies: 0
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 12/24 at 06:40
lol nobody is never happy at all they like to make other ppl unhappy LOL

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.