Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [Problems and Solutions] | Offering a draw in Chess? :([Forum Rules] [Login]

Offering a draw in Chess? :(

Thread #739 - Messages: 6   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 Offering a draw in Chess? :( Message #4196    Replies: 4
posted by rastaro (Ro Fernando) on 11/15 at 19:05

It isnt very clear to me how to offer a daw in Chess at this site.

I effectively lost a move at a crucial stage of a game as I thought that the offer draw worked similar to the offer double in backgammon.

BUT when I ofered the draw to my opponent he made a move instead. This is NO criticism of him at all but it just wasnt clear to me as to how the offer draw option worked. IF one has to click on the offer draw button AFTER a move and BEFORE you click SEND there is no indication that in fact the opponent knows I am offering a draw! I would have expected SOME indication that the 'offer draw' ofer had gone through like for example a message such as "Are you sure you want to offer a draw' or somesuch.

Rohi
 
 Re: Offering a draw in Chess? :( Message #4197    Replies: 0
posted by goofball38 (goofball38) on 11/15 at 20:32
That means he said no, there isn't a verification that says he denied the draw. Sorry.
 
 Re: Offering a draw in Chess? :( Message #4198    Replies: 0
posted by goofball38 (goofball38) on 11/15 at 20:35
And a draw means that the game ends where both people earn 1 point for the game (If in a tournament). Its better used in checkers when 2 players keep making the same moves over and over trying to avoid a legal move that pushes the game in one or the other players favor. A double in backgammon means that you double the points (If playing a points game 5/9/21) It means that the other person agrees that the game they are playing is worth 2 points instead of 1.
 
 Re: Offering a draw in Chess? :( Message #4213    Replies: 0
posted by pomperipossa (Thor Modéen) on 11/17 at 15:15
Clearly a bug. An undecent player could refuse a draw offer by making a move and so make two moves in a row which is very favourable and in fact is impossible according to the chess rules.

In OTB (over the board) chess, the general rule is that a player is not allowed to offer a draw when it is his move, instead he shall make a move and simultanely declare "I offer a draw".

I think TJ has this on his agenda?
 
 Re: Offering a draw in Chess? :( Message #4226    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 11/20 at 10:02
Hi,

Sorry to hear about the trouble. That description of what happened is very strange, there are several things there that don't quite match how draws are supposed to work on Pocket-Monkey.

To offer a draw, you click the Offer Draw button (you don't move a piece first). When you do that, a message appears asking if you're sure you want to offer to end the game in a draw. If you click OK on that message, the game goes to your opponent; it's now their "turn".

When they come into the game, a message appears saying you've offered a draw and asking whether they want to accept. If they do, the game ends in a draw; if not, the game goes back to you -- they don't get an opportunity to move. (They used to, back before May, because of a bug in the site; but we fixed that.)

So that's quite different from what you described. Would you please drop us a note via the Contact Us link with the game number? We'll take a look and discuss it with you further to figure out what happened.

Thanks, and sorry again to hear about the trouble,
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
 stalemate Message #4199    Replies: 0
posted by cobra213 (Paul Melo) on 11/16 at 03:21
the monkey didnt recognize a stalemate. i wasnt too happy when my opponent insisted we play it out so i just resigned

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.